I've had them retain a seal for longer than two years, but eventually, the gaskets harden up, and the washers on the bolts (which really provide the clamping force on the cover) lose their elasticity, and the seepage starts.
It's always cylinder #2 on mine. My VC has been off four times (2x dealer, 2x me), and all my threads are intact.
If the plug tube seepage is the sole issue, and the gasket is relatively new, apply some black RTV sealant (like Permatex Ultra Black) around the seam between the cover and the head.
In your case, that is a lot on #1; replace the gaskets, and just as importantly, the washers.