No pun taken:D
Yeah, personally I like the bottom half of the spoiler. Last night I polished my trunk minus the spoiler. After I went out for an funeral, it started to rain. The original trunk was on the car and rain came in through the pre-drilled holes. When I got home I took my salvaged 325is trunk, cleaned it and replaced the 2 lids. I actually like the no spoiler look.
BTW, I broke down and bought some MHWs.