Picked up the parts this evening, and the new door handle trim is identical to the original, and fits perfectly. Of course, it is a little darker than the old material due to sun fading, but still looks great.
The new roundels, however, are made of plastic.

I tapped on the originals, and they feel like metal. Has anyone replaced their roundels, and were the originals metal? If that's the case, I may look for a used set in good condition.
Looks like the dealership will be a good source for parts. My hood insulation is crumbling, and they can order a replacement set for $45, which is about $15 lower then I found online.