Just suck it up, they are $265 new from the dealer. Welcome to the wonderful world of M42's. Expensive little shits aren't they?
Used one?, They all look like the one you got. If your lucky the water hasn't gone behind the cover, soaked into the gasket, and rusted out the face of the engine block itself. If you replace the cover you will want to replace the oil pump and oil pressure relief valves as well. The oil pressure relief valve was originally steel and is known to seize. When it does you lose oil pressure then then the engine grenades. The old one is steel in a aluminum bore, the superseded part is nylon/composite.
Case Cover:

Block Side, After machining. You can only take about .010" off max, other wise you get a bind with the crank and oil pump.

New timing case. Oh ya, make sure you order the upgraded oil pressure relief valve too. Might as well get a oil pump while you replacing the front cover.

