FIXED!!!
I removed both timing case covers, everything still looked good. I then took off the cam sprockets, chain, tensioner, crank sprocket and lower guide. I didn't see anything that looked out of place. I took the harmonic balancer/pulley assembly and put it on the crank and tried to turn it by hand. Low and behold it moved! I then took a rag and wiped out the lower part of the case before putting the crank sprocket back in and found a piece of the old chain guide about the size of my thumb nail. I reinstalled everything and it cranked over by hand no problem. I guess that little piece of plastic was interfering with the crank sprocket in some way. Hard to believe it was enough to keep me from being able to make it budge.
Only other issue was not being able to get the power steering belt back on. I loosened the screw on the bracket but the pump wouldn't move. The bracket that holds the spark plug wires on the side of the valve cover also broke. Other than that I'm just happy to have this car back on the road.